Tuesday, March 31, 2009

NY Roots: Beer and Blue Sweaters

As my regular bleeps know, I practice "intersectional reading," which basically means that I start reading stuff, get interrupted, then start reading something else, coming back to the other stuff later. Sometimes, it creates interesting insights. And, by hanging a Medici mystique over it, it sounds like an intentional act of serendipity. Like I really should be a professor.

Friends have passed me two interesting books about innovative businesses based in New York. I am a recovering New Yorker (left Upstate in 1976), and one reason I headed West was a sense that the East Coast was a "closed system," too dependent on your family name and where you went to school. But really, the main reason was that the mountains were bigger.

Anyway, Beer School (2005) tells the story of Brooklyn Brewery through the eyes of its founders Steve Hindy and Tom Potter. If you like beer and entrepreneurship, this book is for you (NOTE: I actually drank New Belgium beer while reading this book. But, that is OK karma-wise because someone at New Belgium lent the book to me.) A cool aspect of this book is that the co-founders wrote different chapters , and the other founder chimes in at the end of each chapter with his (sometimes different) perspective. They also grade themselves on how well they built different aspects of the business. It is clear that they had a strong partnership and friendship, but that that this was at times an arduous journey. Dealing with the mob, robberies and almost going broke. My favorite quote from the book:

"There Are No Entrance Exams for Entrepreneurs. No one but you can tell you not to start a business. There are no gatekeepers, no personnel directors and no entrance exams that will keep you out of the entrepreneur's circle. You don't need an MBA; you don't need to have been class president; you don't have to have money. But you do have to decide if you're up to the challenge."

The other book is The Blue Sweater by Jacqueline Novogratz. This book traces the author's work in Africa and how that led to her starting the Acumen Fund, the first non-profit venture capital fund (well, intentionally non-profit, as many VCs are struggling to stay "positive"). I highly recommend this book, for several reasons. First, humility. Novogratz is honest about her experiences and how her initial motivations (to help others; change the world) sometimes reduced her effectiveness. Second, patience and persistence. She discusses patient* capital, referring to financial capital (money). But hers is also a story of patient human capital. That it takes time to learn, build networks, build trust, figure out how to nudge the system. Jacqueline more than put in her 10,000 hours. Third, role model. There is a dearth of well known women entrepreneurs. And few have told the story of their journey. Fourth, inspiration. Her story, and the stories of other entrepreneurs she has known, will inspire you. She kept going, both unlearning and learning as she went. The first step of starting something is to choose to get going. Press the "Go Button" as Francisco Noguera says.

So, the intersectional theme of Beer and Blue Sweaters? Of Brooklyn Brewery and Acumen Fund? Well, it's not just the Big Apple. It is that starting a new venture is a journey. A quest. It is hard work, and at times, tremendously rewarding. When they started, craft brewers and venture philanthropists were little known concepts. Oxymoronic. Crazy intersectional ideas. Now they are both important parts of my world.

Mary Oliver asks a haunting question "So, tell me, what is it you plan to do with your one wild and precious life?" These stories provide Tom, Steve and Jacqueline's answers. What's yours? Whether it is beer or BOP, you won't know until you push the button. There is no entrance exam. Are you up to the challenge?
_________________
*Mitesh Gala believes successful social entrepreneurs need a high "ph factor"- patience and humility. I like "p" for persistence.

Sunday, March 29, 2009

Innovation, Creativity & MBAs

"If you are not prepared to be wrong you will never come up with anything original." Sir Kenneth Robinson (TED 2006).

I had the privilege of hearing Robinson talk at the NCIIA conference in 2008, and he is a great champion of the need to overhaul our educational system.

It's not a bad system, for what it is. In fact, if you wanted to study organizations that are really "Built to Last" you might want to study universities. Some have been around for close to a thousand years! But don't confuse durability with innovation. The nature of the university beast is slow change. Discussion. Consensus. Tenure. There is no real incentive for rapid change. And it is important to be "right" (well, not politically).

It's a shame. Because the university's role is to train the next generation. As Sir Kenneth points out, they do a good job of training the next generation of faculty members, but not the next generation of innovators. It seems to take decades to start new departments, disciplines or degrees, and yet today's fast moving world demands more creative and interdisciplinary people, with skills in team work and cross cultural collaboration.

Universities have survived other crises, and most will survive the current one. But they don't lead society out of crises, and, in fact, may perpetuate the thinking that leads to these crises. Some are wondering if it is time to significantly change MBA programs. I'd add that the founders of America's tech companies did not have MBAs (Gates, Jobs, Brin, Page, etc.).

Robinson talks about 3 leverage points for changing education: curriculum, pedagogy (a term thrown about on campuses but nowhere else) and assessment. These are, to a large extent, controlled by faculty. So I am will not hold my breath for any big changes from the "top" MBA schools. They will continue doing what they are doing.

The changes on these 3 points may come from elsewhere. Clayton Christensen has pointed out that many disruptive innovations come from non-traditional competitors, and has discussed the impact of community colleges on higher education in recent articles. Often disruptive innovations are offered to less valued customers and are perceived as "good enough." A few trends that may be harbingers of MBA disruption: online programs (criticized by many faculty as lacking rigor), foreign students opting for international, rather than come to US schools (who started many of our Silicon Valley start ups?), the growth of partnerships between international schools, and schools such as Bainbridge and Presidio with their sustainability focus. All are trying new approaches to curricula, pedagogy and assessment. While some are seeking just to join the upper tiers, others are trying to reshape the way business is taught, and to make it accessible to more students. Seth Godin has started a free "alternative" MBA.

As with many institutions that are disrupted, the American universities and their business schools may never see it coming. If the recruiters and donors return, many deans will stop wringing their hands. But as business schools trim their budgets in light of endowment drops and state funding cuts, they would do well to remember that now would be a good time to invest in new approaches, rather than perpetuating past practices. I am not sure the planet, our society or our communities can take much more Business As Usual.

Thursday, March 26, 2009

What's your BHAWG?

In Built to Last, Jim Collins and Jerry Porras suggested that successful companies use BHAGs ("Big Hairy Audacious Goals") to articulate their vision and engage stakeholders. Some of the companies lauded in BTL have fallen on tough times in the decade since the book came out. But there is no question that the guiding principles outlined by the authors have had a huge impact on business people, politicians and other leaders. And among the stickiest is the BHAG. It is now part of the vernacular (even if it still isn't in dictionary*). I think it is on almost every buzzword bingo card.

I have a modest suggestion. BHAG needs a tweak. Sure, goals can inspire and focus people. I like thinking "big"... "hairy" is OK... and "audacious" is a great word. And yet... Citigroup had a BHAG. BHAGs can go wrong. Author Paul Carroll (Billion Dollar Lessons) points out in his blog that BHAGs can distort behavior and points to IBM. Carroll suggests "If you’re going to establish a BHAG, first think about all the ways it could lead to problems... Proceed with humility." (Can you be audacious, yet humble?) He concludes, "it's easy to get a BHAG wrong."

My advice? Entrepreneurs and BOPreneurs should set BHAWGs- Big Hairy Audacious WORTHY Goals. Make your goods good, your services serve. Use the inherent advantages of business to achieve positive impacts. Do good, and be great at it.
__________________
*side note, evidently "bhag" is in some dictionaries as the Sanskrit root for "hot"... and is also a proper name.